Thursday, March 18, 2010

Beowulf vs Gawain

Beowulf versus Sir Gawain
Joe Rivet




Beowulf is an ideal hero in the time period of the eighteenth century. In that time period, a hero was defined as a person who was strong and courageous. Sir Gawain on the other hand was written for the time period about six centuries earlier. During the time of Sir Gawain, a hero was measured by how well they could follow their morals and how true they were to the ideals of chivalry. There are of course a few ways in which the stories of Sir Gawain and Beowulf and similar but there are many more ways in which they differ. Comparing the two stories shows us a great deal about how the image of the ideal hero has changed a great deal over time. The most prominent differences between the two characters are the way they speak of themselves, the role that religion plays in their respective quests, the way they act when they are confronted with women and the motives that they each have for fighting their enemies.
Both Beowulf and Gawain were deemed to be “perfect” by their peers, but when Sir Gawain introduces himself he speaks of himself as the least of the knights at Arthur’s round table. He plainly shows us this when he says: “I am the weakest, well I know, and of wit feeblest; and the loss of my life would be least of any; that I have Arthur for an uncle is my only praise; my body, but for your blood, is barren of worth." (Lines 354-355) This is the ultimate show of humility which is what all knights and heroes of this time were supposed to show.
Beowulf on the other hand, showed himself to have a great deal of confidence in himself. He boasts of his feats of strength when we see him. The knights of Gawain’s time were supposed to present themselves with incredible amounts of humility and modesty. If Beowulf is representative of the warriors of his time, then it seems that the image of an ideal hero has shifted quite a bit. Beowulf is not shy at all to bypass all illusions of humility and try to put himself in the best light possible.
Beowulf’s method of talking about yourself is far more common than Gawain’s method in today’s world. Now if anyone does something deserving of praise they are encouraged to praise themselves for it although they are certainly not encouraged to exaggerate about it to make themselves look as Beowulf seems to be doing on some occasions.
Another one of the major differences that we encounter between Gawain and Beowulf is physical combat. Most of Beowulf’s fights are only mentioned briefly, but the three fights in which Beowulf participates in the poem are described in great detail. Each time the hero of the story Beowulf, is confronted by a horrible monster and all three times he shows us that he is worthy of his title as an almost undefeatable warrior. Although he ultimately loses the final fight to the dragon, he still fights valiantly and even when he is dying afterwards, he is still trying to do what he thinks will be best for his kingdom by passing on the kingship to the best possible choice.
Sir Gawain’s story is not the same as Beowulf’s in this regard. Physical combat is mentioned only shortly throughout the tale. Gawain’s ability and skills with weapons are mentioned and praised throughout the story, but stories about his actual battles seem to hold less importance than Gawain’s determination to keep his honor by keeping the promise he made to the Green Knight to show up for a duel. This is a fundamental difference between the characters of Beowulf and Gawain. Honor is also important to Beowulf’s story but to a lesser degree. To Beowulf, the glory you get out of defeating a monster and collecting its spoils is a greater reward then the glory you get out of keeping your word to your enemy.
Again, Beowulf’s views on glory more closely resemble today’s views than Gawain’s beliefs do. Most people today would rather defeat their enemy and collect the spoils from the battle than keep their word by showing up for a duel they had promised a long time ago. Gawain certainly fulfills his codes of honor as a knight by showing up for the duel even though he is almost certain that he may not come out of it alive. Most people alive today would not look at this as honor. Instead they would be more likely to call Gawain a fool for walking into his death to fulfill something as unimportant as his honor when he could have just as easily never left his castle in Camelot.
One of the biggest differences between the two heroes is the way they view women they come across. To Gawain and the knights of his time, a lady was to be treated with even more respect than they would treat another man. Gawain shows us just how highly knights think of women when he meets the lady of the castle. He declares that he is her servant and he will do whatever he can to please her.
Beowulf’s attitude towards women is much more casual. The few times women come up in the story of Beowulf, his actions toward them reflect his casual attitude. He seems to view them as just another thing that is there to give him the chance to enhance his glory.
Amid all these differences between the two heroes, there is one thing that makes them similar. They are both expected to uphold a rigorous code of morals and rules. It was his code of honor that made Beowulf try to rescue Hrothgar when he was in trouble. Gawain’s code is the only thing that kept him from going back to Camelot when he was afraid for his life because of his upcoming duel with the green knight. The chivalry code of the knights was undoubtedly stricter than Beowulf’s rather relaxed moral code, but the feeling of being required to follow their honor codes is obviously there in both of these stories.
In conclusion, the two characters of Sir Gawain and Beowulf are fundamentally different in many ways but they also have something important in common which is how rigidly they follow their respective set of rules. This shows us that no matter how much certain things about the ideal hero image may change over time, the ideal hero will always follow their honor code to the letter. Being able to follow these types of codes as strictly as we see Beowulf and Gawain doing is what can make one a hero.

No comments:

Post a Comment